Office: A204-I, phone x4528
Office hrs: M,W 11:30-12:30
Home phone: 243-8261 M,
W 4:30- 5:30
E-mail: moen@mail.hartford.edu
R 2:00- 4:00
Homepage: moen@mail.hartford.edu/~moen
& by appointment
I. Description
of Course Content: This course concentrates on major thinkers
and themes
during the "classical"
period of American philosophy (1870-1945) in the United States. It
sets the background
for the classical period by introducing some earlier U.S. thinkers, and
then turns to its focus
on C.S. Peirce, William James, Josiah Royce, John Dewey and G.H.
Mead. It includes also
W.E.B. Du Bois, Alain Locke, Jane Addams, Charlotte P. Gilman,
and George Santayana.
The purpose of the course is to reach an understanding of the
authors’ reasoning—an
understanding that is both empathic and critical, and is mindful of
the historical and
cultural contexts to which the authors were responding. The course ends
with discussion of
the contemporary renewal of interest in "pragmatism"—the most
distinctive strand
of American philosophy—and diverse directions present within that renewal.
II. Texts:
A. Required
texts for purchase:
1. Stuhr, John, ed. Classical American Philosophy: Essential Readings
and
Interpretive Essays. Oxford & New York: Oxford UP, 1987.
[hereafter "Stuhr"]
2. Rosenthal, Sandra, C.Hausman and D Anderson, eds. Classical AmericanB. Other required texts, and recommended readings:
Pragmatism: Its Contemporary Vitality. Chicago: U Illinois Press, 1999.
[hereafter "RHA"]
• Other materials on reserve for the course in Mortenson will be mentionedC. On-line resources: a list of recommended sites will be provided.
from time to time as recommended readings. These materials will also
serve as good starting points for your research papers.
III. Goals
and Objectives: Students who successfully complete this
course will be
able to meet the following objectives:
• to identify main themes of classical American philosophy, its
major
contributors, and some specific contributions of each of the latter
• to identify historical and cultural conditions in and through which those
themes emerged, and those contributors attained voice and recognition
• to compare and contrast distinct agendas and methodologies put
forward by different thinkers within our classical period (1870-1945
• to read and understand primary source material in philosophy, by practicingIV. Assignments and Grading:
both modes of analytical reading: the empathic and the critical
• to extract significant concepts and arguments from primary texts
• to begin to evaluate these arguments with regard to their strengths and
limitations; their implications for further inquiry; and their potential impact
on ‘real-world’ issues• to conduct inquiry for a short independent project. This means to sense the
presence of a conceptual and/or practical problem; to specify the problem;
to gather relevant information as needed and interpret that information
conceptually
• to assess the results of the inquiry project and to suggest further directions
of inquiry• to express the results of interpretive study, and the results of inquiry, in prose
that is clear, logically sound, and effectively structured.These specific course objectives are in keeping the the general goals of the
Philosophy Department, which are to foster students’ growth in four areas:
(1) basic knowledge of philosophical history and practice; (2) analytical-interpretive
reading; (3) design and conduct of inquiry; and (4) expression/communication,
especially in speech and writing.
• Ten (10) "daily" writing assignments @ 10 points each 100 pointsV. Rules and Expectations:
These will average 1-2 pages each.• Three (3) take-home exams (essays) @ 100 points each 300 points
These should be 3-5 pages each.• Independent research paper, 8-10 pages 100 points
You will also report briefly to the class on your research.• Participation: attendance, appropriate participation in class
discussions and small-group work, occasional on-line
assignments, and maintenance of a "portfolio" consisting
of your collected written work for the course. 100 pointstotal: 600 points
1. Attend every class. Have assignments for the day completed. Be respectful of
your co-learners (classmates and professor).Ordinarily late assignments will suffer a grade penalty and will not be
accepted at all after one week. (Penalty: 20 points for each late day on
exams and papers worth 100 points; 2 points per late day on daily writing
assignments worth 10 points each.) Exceptions will be made in special
circumstances such as serious illness, travel with athletic teams, etc.
2. You are encouraged to study together; you may brainstorm together inVI. Tentative Schedule: We will try to follow this schedule as closely as possible, but
preparation for papers; but in the end, your written work must be your own.
Plagiarism consists of presenting someone else’s work as though it were
your own. The penalty is failure for the entire course. While working on your
independent research paper, be sure to use proper documentation. Ask
for advice if you are uncertain.
| DATE |
READING DUE FOR DISCUSSION
and other learning activities |
WRITTEN WORK DUE |
| W 9/1 | Introduction to the course and to one another | |
| M 9/6 | LABOR DAY HOLIDAY - NO CLASS | |
| W 9/8 | Read:
Introductions to the two main texts.
In-class viewing of video on Transcendentalism |
Response to text
"Introductions" (1 page)
|
| M 9/13 | In-class viewing of video on the Pragmatists | |
| W 9/15 | Discussion of text "Intro"s and of videos | Response to the two videos. (1 page) |
| M 9/20 | INTRODUCING
PEIRCE:
Peirce (in Stuhr): [total = 12 pages] - p. 32, from "Some consequences..." - pp. 33-37, fr. "How to make ideas clear" - pp. 62-63, "Phenomenology" - pp. 81-84, "Methodeutic" (fr. "Fixation") Lachs (in RHA):
|
"Prep-sheet" on Peirce, pp. 33-37, from "How to make ideas clear" NB: precise format for prep-sheets is explained
below, following this schedule.
|
| W 9/22 | INTRODUCING
JAMES:
James (in Stuhr): [total = 14 pages] - pp. 125-29, "World of pure experience" - pp. 135-43, "What Pragmatism means" - pp. 152-54, fr. "Moral philosopher, moral life" - pp. 171-72, fr. "Will to believe" Seigfried (in RHA):
|
Prep-sheet on James, pp. 135-43, "What Pragmatism means."
|
| M 9/27 | INTRODUCING
ROYCE:
Royce (in Stuhr): [total = 13 pages] - pp. 224-232, fr. "The Body and its members" - pp. 245-248. fr. "Loyalty to loyalty" |
Prep-sheet on Royce, pp. 224-232, "The Body and its members" |
| W 9/29 | INTRODUCE
SANTAYANA & DU BOIS:
Santayana (in Stuhr): [total = 5 pages] - pp. 277-78 Preface-"Scepticism & animal faith" - pp. 279-81 "Ultimate scepticism" Du Bois (on reserve in Mortenson
Lib.)
|
Prep-sheet on either Santayana, pp. 279-81, "Ultimate scepticism" OR Du Bois reading. |
| M 10/4 | INTRODUCING
DEWEY:
Dewey (in Stuhr): [total = 21 pages] - p.359, fr. "Experience & philosophic method" - pp. 383-88, "The Lost individual" - pp. 388-95, fr. "Search for the great community" - pp. 400-405, "The Live creature and aesthetic experience" Guinlock (in RHA):
* Take-home exam #1 distributed at end of class. Due in 1 week. |
Prep-sheet on Dewey, pp. 383-88, "Lost individual" |
| W 10/6 | INTRODUCING
MEAD:
Mead (in Stuhr): [ 13 pages] - pp. 430-32, "Social psychology, behaviorism, and the concept of gesture" - pp. 443-49, "The Nature of reflective intelligence" - pp. 447-50, "The Self and the organism" - pp. 450-52, "Self, generalized other, ‘I’ and ‘me’" Aboulafia (in RHA): - pp. 120-133, "Mead: Social experience and the individual" * Sign-up sheet provided in class
—
|
Prep-sheet on Mead, pp. 450-452, "Self, generalized other, ‘I’ and ‘me.’" |
| M 10/11 | Individual conferences to assess progress and plan independent research project. | ** Take-home
exam #1
due. |
| W 10/13 | Individual conferences continued. | # Research paper topic and initial bibliography due. |
| M 10/18 | REVISITING
PEIRCE:
We will now read through most of the Peirce selections in Stuhr, including what we read before. The page numbers listed for particular days below are approximate. They are meant to help you pace your extended reading of Peirce. You will receive advice in class about what you should concentrate on and what, if anything, you may skip from the material on pages 13-48. You will be assigned to small, in-class groups. For purposes of your written response to this material, different groups will concentrate on different readings. Groups will work together for part of the class period, and then will report to the whole class. - Peirce (in Stuhr): pp. 13-48 (This
includes a
Begin reading one of the following (to
be
|
Prep-sheet on an assigned segment of today’s Peirce material from Stuhr. NB: everyone in a particular group will
do a prep-sheet on the same material. Nobody
Your group affiliation and your group’s precise assignment will be based on your particular interests and the instructor’s discretion. |
| W 10/20 | Again, you will
be instructed during the previous
class period regarding which segments of the reading you should concentrate on most. - Peirce (in Stuhr): pp. 49-65 - Continue working on one of the articles
on
|
# Prospectus
for research paper due. (To be somewhat more developed than your original
statement of topic.)
|
| M 10/25 | (Segments for concentration
to be determined).
-Peirce (in Stuhr): pp. 66-91 - Continue working on one of the articles on Peirce in RHA (i.e. Colapietro, Anderson, or Hausman). |
Prep-sheet on an assigned segment of the Peirce material OR on one of the articles from RHA. |
| W 10/27 | REVISITING
JAMES:
(Segments for concentration to be determined). -James (in Stuhr): pp. 93-125 Begin reading one of the following (to
be assigned) from RHA:
|
# Annotated
bibliography
for independent research papers due. (The type and extent of
|
| M 11/1 | (Segments for concentration
to be determined).
-James (in Stuhr): pp. 125-76 - Continue working on one of the articles on James in RHA (i.e. Stuhr, Fontinell, or Parker). * Take-home exam #2 distributed at end of class. Due in 1 week. |
Prep-sheet on an
assigned segment of today’s James material from the Stuhr
anthology.
|
| W 11/3 | REVISITING
ROYCE:
(Segments for concentration to be determined). - Royce (in Stuhr): pp. 178-244 |
|
| M 11/8 | (Segments for concentration
to be determined).
- Royce (in Stuhr): pp. 245-67 |
** Take-home exam #2 due. |
| W 11/10 | REVISITING
DEWEY:
(Segments for concentration to be determined). - Dewey (in Stuhr): pp. 320-68 Begin reading one of the following (to
be assigned) from RHA:
|
|
| M 11/15 | (Segments for concentration
to be determined).
- Dewey (in Stuhr): pp. 369-87 - Jane Addams: on reserve in Mortenson
Library;
- Continue working on one of the articles
on
|
Prep-sheet on an
assigned segment of the Dewey
material. |
| W 11/17 | (Segments for concentration
to be determined).
- Dewey (in Stuhr): pp. 388-417 - Continue working on one of the articles on Dewey in RHA (i.e. Boisvert, Hickman, or Alexander). |
# Complete draft
of
research paper due. |
| M 11/22 | AFRICAN-AMERICAN
PHILOSOPHY
during the Classical Period - Du Bois: on reserve in Mortenson
Library;
* Take-home exam #3 distributed
at end of
|
Prep-sheet on an assigned selection from Du Bois or Locke. |
| W 11/24 | THANKSGIVING HOLIDAY - NO CLASS | |
| M 11/29 | REVISITING
MEAD:
(Segments for concentration to be determined). -Mead (in Stuhr): pp. 419-32; 443-50; 460-68 Read one of the following from RHA:
|
|
| W 12/1 | THE
CONTEMPORARY RESURGENCE
of Pragmatism as a Philosophy Recommended readings on this topic will be on reserve in Mortenson Library. Specific recommen-dations will be announced; they will doubtless include Cornel West, Richard Rorty, Charlene Seigfried and Nancy Fraser. |
** Take-home exam #3 due. |
| M 12/6 | STUDENT PRESENTATIONS
Each student will be assigned a particular time on one of these last three days for sharing the results of his or her research project with the class. These presentations will be informal and should take no more than 5-10 minutes each. |
|
| W 12/8 | STUDENT PRESENTATIONS | |
| M 12/13 | STUDENT PRESENTATIONS
|
# Final Draft
Research
Paper Due. |
| Back to Moen homepage. |
VII. Other Relevant Information Regarding Assignments:
It enables you to come to class well prepared
for listening and discussion.
Initially our discussions will be conducted
as a whole class. Later you will
work together, on certain days, in smaller
groups. The prep-sheets will greatly
facilitate productive small-group work.
Format for a prep-sheet: a prep-sheet
has four parts: Analysis, Evaluation,
Directions for Inquiry, and Personal Response.
Here they are in more detail:
1. ANALYSIS:
• A prep-sheet will probably require 1-2
pages, if it is planned well. If you find
it helpful to write more than that, however,
you are free to do so. Prep-sheets
should be typed, preferably on a word-processor.
• I will provide you with a sample prep-sheet
or two, to help you understand
what you need to do.
• Rewrites will normally be permitted,
but only providing the paper was
originally submitted on time.
Ordinarily there is no re-write option on
late papers.
• When feasible, I will post "study help"
on my homepage rather than using
hardcopy handouts. I will also post any
changes in assignments, or other
relevant announcements, so that if you
forget something that was announced
in class, you can consult the web page
to refresh your memory. Another type
of help that you fill find on my web page
is a set of links to sites of special
value to students of American philosophy.
• We will be organizing some mode of electronic
discussion of course-related
issues. You will not be required
to participate in this exchange. However,
intelligent participation may make you
eligible for extra credit.