Policy Analysis Paper

[ Home ] [ Up ] [ Links ]

This paper has two purposes. First, you are to present an account of the current state of policy in a particular area and the positions of the parties which most proximately form this policy. Second, you are to present a compelling argument for a particular policy position.

You can structure your paper in any way that you would like. You can have it structured so that you address the nine points in turn, or you might decide another format is more conducive to good organization of the paper.

It must be 9-11 standard double spaced typed pages. It is due the Tuesday before you are scheduled to debate the topic. Full formal citations are required. See Citation Style Guides - University of Alberta Libraries.

Mapping the policy domain

Summarize the current state of policymaking in your area, making sure to include the following information:

Levels of policymaking and administration: To what extent do state, local, or federal agencies deal with this policy area?

House and Senate Committees and subcommittees, including background of leading members of committees and subcommittees.

Administrative agencies, including background of major administrators

Interest groups, including industry groups; trade groups; ideological/public interest groups

Links between players. What associations are there between interest groups and government officials? Follow the money: use campaign contribution information to determine which interest groups support committee chairs

Judicial influence: Do the courts play a significant role in this policy area? Who is litigating what?

Current state of federal and state law

Major proposal(s) being considered to reform current law

Positions of various players, including Committee heads, House and Senate party leadership, administrative heads, different interest groups, courts

Taking a position

Make a compelling argument on particular policy under debate within your research area. The particular question you will address and the position you take in your paper must be chosen in consultation with your debate partner(s).