Amending the Constitution 1999
 

Background
Participants
Recommended Amendments
Convention Rules
Proposed Amendments
New Federalist Papers

Teachers' Resources
Suggested Activities

Questions or 
comments:
constcon99@aol.com

 

Question: Should the United States adopt proportional representation?

In the United States, almost all legislative elections are run on the "winner-take-all" system in which the person winning the most votes in a particular district is the only person elected to represent that district. Many democracies use what is called "proportional representation," in which several legislators are elected from each district and each party receives legislative seats in proportion to the percentage of the vote received. Advocates of proportional representation say that this is more fair since it allows more than the candidate or party who comes in first to have a share of legislative power. Consider what the advantages and disadvantages of such a system might be. 



Resources:

Proportional Representation Library 
This is an exhaustive and well-documented set of web resources on proportional representation compiled and maintained by Douglas J. Amy, Professor of Politics at Mt. Holyoke College and author of Real Choices, New Voices: The Case for Proportional Representation Elections in the United States 

Proportional Representation FAQ
Written by Edward LaBonte

Center for Voting and Democracy
The CVD is an organization dedicated to promoting proportional representation and other electoral reforms
 
 

CREC School for International Studies: American Government
University of Hartford